Lubrication and SCUBA Valve Installation
In general purpose applications, the lubrication of joining threads will reduce galvanic action between dissimilar metals and when joining tapered threads is useful to reduce galling. This is especially true when the very tight join alone is responsible for providing a seal. Aluminum metal is notable for it's susceptibility to galling. Lubrication of O-rings helps protect against wear, abrasion, pinching, or cutting. As a result, conventional wisdom and "common sense" says to always lubricate threads and O-rings. However, the benefit of using lubrication during installation of valves in SCUBA cylinders is debatable.
In our own research and experience we can't find any objective basis for recommending lubrication with properly maintained SCUBA tanks where the valve is removed and O-ring seal replaced on the annual VIP maintenance schedule recommended by our industry. SCUBA valves already have a relatively low potential for galvanic action due to the inherent nature of their materials. Modern SCUBA valve inlet threads are straight, not tapered, and galling (even in aluminum cylinders) is not a concern unless the valve is improperly over-tightened into the cylinder neck. The threads are not intended to provide a seal in this application; the high-pressure seal is provided by a captured O-ring. The unique design of the captured O-ring seal between the SCUBA valve and cylinder neck will not damage the O-ring during assembly, nor is it subject to wear. While oxygen compatible lubrication of the neck threads and O-ring in SCUBA valves and cylinders is probably harmless under ideal conditions, it also has no clear benefit.
Generic cylinder and valve maintenance guides rarely address the specific nature of the SCUBA industry, especially in regards to Nitrox applications. Since the valve, O-ring, cylinder and lubricant manufacturers in any assembled SCUBA tank are all different, it's commonplace to find conflicting recommendations regarding use of lubricant. Our suppliers do agree that nearly all installation, sealing and removal problems are caused by improper technique and over-tightening the valve into the cylinder, not the absence of lubricant. Some local dive shops intentionally avoid all lubricant, some use it very sparingly and others use it liberally. The bottom line is that lubrication use in this SCUBA application seems to be a matter of opinion, not evidence based science.
Lubrication, even oxygen compatible lubrication, is not considered best practice for cylinders and valves used with medical oxygen or industrial oxygen. That's because while oxygen compatible lubricants might have higher temperatures of ignition than hydrocarbons, they can still serve as fuel in the kindling chain of an oxygen fire. Any lubricant will attract and retain contaminates, plus there is the significant risk that an incompatible lubricant might be applied. In our opinion, legitimate oxygen safety concerns outweigh the questionable benefits espoused by those recommending lubrication in SCUBA cylinder and valve Nitrox applications.
Dive Gear Express currently does not recommend any form of lubricant, including oxygen compatible lubricant, when installing our Nitrox Ready SCUBA valves in oxygen clean cylinders.